The Hidden History

Peter H. Proctor, PhD, MD

Forman (1) reviews the role of reactive species in cell signaling, e.g., noting Szent-Gyorgyi's conjectures concerning a role for electronic mobility in biological materials as a mechanism for (say) hormonal action. Interestingly, the first empirical evidence for electronically-activated processes in cell signaling was clinical observation (2).

Examples include the long-known association of radical-generating agents such as copper, iron, or manganese with specific symptomology. This includes dyskineas ( movement disorders ) and other neuropsychiatric symptoms, diabetes, fibrosis, and deafness, as well as associated-changes in the skin pigment melanin (reviews, 2-5).

For example, the skin pigment melanin is the only overtly-visible biological free radical. Melanin was also the first well-defined free radical in biological systems (38). In addition to skin, visible melanin is present in extradermal structures such as the inner ear and in catecholaminergic nerve cell bodies in the midbrain substantia nigra, and locus caeruleus. In such structures it may have a role in cellular function, in dopamine, serotonin, and norepinephrine-mediated cell signaling, and in organ development.

Thus, Charles Darwin ( 6 ) proposes that �..a slight arrest of development in the nervous system..� may explain deafness in white, blue-eyed cats. CNS development is per se a messenger-mediated process. Likewise, light exposure induces dermal melanin synthesis, another complex and closely-regulated cellular process.

Similarly, hyperbaric oxygen causes seizures, a reactive oxygen species (ROS ) -mediated process difficult to explain by simple tissue damage. Interocular copper or iron produce vitreous fibrosis disproportionate to actual damage. Further, in hemochromatosis and Wilson's disease iron or copper deposition accompany liver fibrosis or �cirrhosis�, skin pigmentation abnormalities, psychosis, and dyskinesia (2-5). The neuropsychiatric symptoms of Wilson's disease appear before any overt evidence of tissue damage, while another name for hemochromatosis is bronze diabetes.

Likewise, Hoffer and Osmond's Adrenochrome Hypothesis ( 7 ) holds that psychoactive oxidation products of catecholamines (adrenochromes ) figure in the etiology of schizophrenia and other neuropsychiatric diseases. Now long-supplanted, but the basic concept is correct. Interestingly, this work resulted in the use of nicotinic acid in the treatment of hypercholesterolemia and dyslipidemia. Six-decades later, this is still a primary treatment for dyslipidemias when statins are contra-indicated.

Another key discovery was the isolation of orgotein (11). This anti-inflammatory blue copper-zinc protein from bovine liver was eventually approved for veterinary as well as human use in some countries as an antiinflammatory and radioprotective agent. Orgotein proved to be ZnCu superoxide dismutase (SOD1). This provided a major tie-in between inflammation and other pathogenic processes such as cancer cell growth and redox cell signaling. Stated-simply-- an effect on inflammation is mechanistically too complicated to be simply-assigned to preventing non-specific tissue damage, particularly when we already knew that (e.g.) dopaminergic neurotransmission likely involves reactive species.

George Cotzias, Neuromelanin, and Levodopa for Parkinson's Disease

Over four decades ago, Cotzias and coworkers noted (8,9) the likely role of mid-brain melanin and charge-transfer processes ( including oxidative stress ) in (e.g.) chronic manganism and other extrapyramidal syndromes, particularly Parkinsonism. Patton (10) quotes Cotzias: �I don't believe God put the melanin granule in the central nervous system for nothing. It must be doing something. Something big, something that will win me the Noble prize." Eventually this led to their development of Levodopa therapy for Parkinson's disease( 9 ) -- again, still a primary treatment.

Redox-Mediated Neurotransmission

Similarly, in the late 1960's, we encountered a patient with Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome. Lesch-Nyhan's is characterized by massive overproduction of purines and their metabolite uric acid, along with bizarre behavior (including self-mutilation ) and choreoathetoid dyskinesia. Significantly, this patient had originally been diagnosed as �schizophrenic�. Lesch-Nyhans Syndrome is now thought a primary model for bipolar mania. This disorder is often acutely-indistinguishable from schizophrenia, except by clinical history.

Thus oxidative and nitrosative stress likely plays a role in bipolar and maigraine comorbidity. See, e.g.,The Comorbidity of Bipolar Disorder and Migraine: The Role of Inflammation and Oxidative and Nitrosative Stress.. The same authors report that the xanthine oxidase-inhibitor allopurinol works in bipolar mania.

Synthesis of uric acid by xanthine oxidase produces reactive oxygen species. On the other hand, oxypurines are powerful-reducing agents. Thus, the classic clinical assay for urate depends upon its singular ability to directly reduce phosphotungstic acid, a property it shares with another antioxidant reducing substance, ascorbate (2). Also like ascorbate, uric acid is conditionally pro-oxidant (2), as are other purines (12).

Thus, drawing upon Cotzias et al (8) we proposed that electron-transfer processes produce the neuropsychiatric symptoms of Lesch-Nyhan's (2-6, 13-16), as they do those of chronic manganism. Most-importantly, oxidative-stress-mediated tissue damage alone seemed an unlikely cause of such bizarre and specific messenger-mediated neuropsychiatric symptoms as self-mutilation and choreoathetoid dyskinesia. The same seemed to hold for analogous symptoms in alcaptonuria, etc. (2-5,12-16).

Even four decades ago, the clear implication was that electron-transfer processes likely specifically mediate CNS cellular function-- say, by �doping� some organic semiconductor such as neuromelanin (2) and/or by (e.g.) modulating dopaminergic processes (13). This phenomenon is but one manifestation of what is now dubbed �redox signaling�.

Subsequent workers ( e.g.,17-20) refined the role of both dopaminergic processes and oxidative stress in Lesch-Nyhan's syndrome. Similarly, urate and/or xanthine oxidase-induced oxidative-stress have been implicated in (e.g.) atherosclerosis (6, 21), stroke (18,22,23), and diabetes (7, 23, 24 ). Moreover, SOD ameliorates hyperuricemic syndrome in Dalmatian dogs ( 25,26 ). As further proof of concept, such animals also tend to be both deaf and �bronzed� (25), a visible sign of underlying electronically-activated processes.

Likewise, higher primates have uniquely lost both the ability to make ascorbate and to break-down uric acid. So, we suggested that urate may substitute for ascorbate in human evolution (27), say, as an antioxidant or enzyme cofactor. Most importantly, �this does not exclude other physiological roles for uric acid� (27) . Other proposed functions (2-5) of uric acid and similar charge-transfer agents such as homocysteine included (e.g.) acting as a pro- or anti-oxidant, a �dopant� for some semiconducting biopolymer such as neuromelanin, or some more direct action as a cellular messenger. Accordingly, urate elevation is now in clinical trials for both stroke and Parkinson's disease.

Such multifunctionality ( including cell signaling ) has proven the case. However, researchers can still only speculate whether uric acid is causative, ameliorative, or (most likely) both in, e.g., atherosclerosis and stroke (22-24). We likewise extended this to more human diseases and more characteristic symptoms ( 2-5 ). This includes additional putative oxidative-stress-related symptoms such as psychosis, pigmentary abnormalities, and deafness, as well as atherosclerosis and diabetes ( e.g., in hemochromatosis ). E.g., ref (2) seems to be the first suggestion that homocysteine pathogenesis involves oxidative stress.

Szent-Gyorgyi* Vindicated

Investigating another aspect of redox signaling and as proof of concept for McGinness' mobility gap conduction model (28), we also constructed (29) an �active� organic polymer electronic device. An "active" device is one in which a current or voltage controls resistivity, as in a transistor. This was a voltage-controlled bistable switch using melanin. The �ON� state of this switch exhibits almost metallic conductivity. Significantly, doping with charge-transfer agents associated with (e.g.) neuropsychiatric symptomology modulated the electrical properties of the device, a la Szent-Gyorgyi. Cytochrome-C also switched, but at a much higher voltage gradient, though one achievable in vivo.

Concerning this device, Hush's history (36) of organic electronics states: �Also in 1974 came the first experimental demonstration of an operating molecular electronic device that functions along the lines of the biopolymer conduction ideas of Szent-Gyorgi.�. Hush also notes that the electronically-active material exhibits negative differential resistance, a hall-mark of present-day electronically-active organic polymers. Similar materials are now used in actual (literally) printed circuits. Organic electronics is also part of �nanotechnology�. So this is arguably the first �nanotech� device, well before the term was coined. Paradoxically, although virtually unknown in redox cell signalling, this organic semiconductor electronic device is now on the short Smithsonian chips list (37) of historic milestones in a rather different area, semiconductor physics and technology. It is also in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History's collection of historic electrical devices.** This device may also be an early example of protonic conduction in biological materials.

For more modern examples of the possible role of organic semiconductor processes in redox signaling, see references 39 and 40.

Redox Signaling Initially Rejected

By the late 1970's, convincing evidence had accumulated indicating redox signaling is a general phenomenon, mediating much more than neuropsychiatric symptoms and dermal melanization. We also had experimental evidence (28,29) supporting Szent-Gyorgyi's conjectures about conductive biological polymers and their modulation by charge-transfer processes. So, at a 1979 �International Congress of Free Radical Researchers� we proposed (21) that "One explanation for this data is that various active oxygen species ( or such products as hydroperoxides ) may act as specific transmitter substances" and �...We suggest that active oxygen metabolites act as specific intermediary transmitter substances for a variety of biological processes including inflammation, fibrosis, and possibly, neurotransmission ..".

Simply-stated, electron-transfer processes mediate, e.g.. dyskinetic symptoms in various diseases, self-mutilation in Lesch-Nyhan's, and melanocyte function. So why not also equally complex processes such as (say) inflammation and fibrosis ?

This initial effort to generalize the concept of redox signaling failed to gain traction. In fact, due to strong reviewer objection, this manuscript was omitted from the published proceedings of the conference, although another paper from our group was included (30). Among other things, the latter paper reports (as did others at the meeting) that superoxide dismutase suppresses tumor growth in experimental animals. This was one more indirect confirmation of the cellular messenger properties of reactive species. ROS are now known to be important mediators of cell growth and replication in cancer.

Now a given, for a time opposition to a messenger role for electronically-active species was so strong that it took years to publish. Tellingly, this was only by taking advantage of the freedom allowed reviews and invited book chapters (4,5).

Eventually, other researchers such as Bochner et al ( 31 ) began to relate oxidative stress to modulation of specific biochemical pathways, making the concept more generally-palatable. By the mid-1990's, the concept was respectable enough that major review articles started to appear (39). Meanwhile, the early work had been forgotten.


*Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1941b. The study of energy-levels in biochemistry. Nature 148 (3745), 157�159. Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1957. Bioenergetics. Academic Press, New York. Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1960. Introduction to a Submolecular Biology. Academic Press, New York. Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1968. Bioelectronics. Academic Press, New York. Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1976. Electronic Biology and Cancer. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York. Szent-Gyorgyi, A., 1978. The Living State and Cancer. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York.

** However, as Nicolaus and Parisi note (34), all melanins are polyacetylenes and vice-versa. Well before us, other researchers reported passive "resister-like" high conductivity in polyacetylene derivatives. E.g., highly-conductive iodine-doped polyaniline "melanins" were first reported in 1963 (32,33). By the mid 1960's, researchers achieved conductivities less than 1 ohm/cm, comparable to present-day efforts.

Remarkably, the 1977 rediscovery of passive high conductivity in almost-identical iodine-"doped" oxidized polyacetylenes (35) eventually won the 2000 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for " the discovery and development of conductive polymers...''. In an unprecedented lapse, the Nobel committee completely missed the previous substantial body of research on highly-conductive polyacetylene derivatives, of which we were merely the last.

Thus, Inzelt's textbook "Conductive Polymers" ( 33 ) contests the Nobel �discovery� assignment, noting that such highly-conductive polymers were well-known and had even been applied well before the work of the Nobel laureates. The �development� part also involved a restatement of McGinness' mobility-gap model for electronic conduction in organic polymers (28)-- e.g., adding the special case of soliton migration in pure polyacetylene.


1 Forman, H.J. Signal transduction and reactive species. Free Radic. Biol. Med. 47:1237-1238; 2009

2 Proctor, P. H. Electron-transfer factors in psychosis and dyskinesia, Phvsiol. Chem. Phvs. 4:349-360; 1972.

3 Proctor, P. H. The role of melanin in human neurological disorders. Pigment Cell 3:378-382; 1976.

4 Proctor, P. H., Reynolds, E.S. Free radicals and disease in man. Physiol. Chem. Phys. 16:175-195; 1984

5 Proctor, P.H., Free Radical Mechanisms in Human Disease, CRC Handbook of Free Radicals and Antioxidants in Biomedicine, Vol 1. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp. 209-221. 1989.

6 Darwin, C., The variation of animals and plants under domestication. John Murray, London, p322, 1868

7 Hoffer, A.; Osmond H., The Adrenchrome Model and Schizophrenia, J. Nerv. Mental Dis. 128:18-35; 1959.

8 Cotzias, G.C.; Papavasiliou P.S.; Van Woert M.H.; Sakamoto A. Melanogenesis and extrapyramidal diseases. Fed. Proc. 23:713-18; 1964

9 Cotzias, G.C.; Papavasiliou P.S.; Ginos J.; Steck A.; Duby, S, Metabolic Modification of Parkinson's Disease and of Chronic Manganese Poisoning. Annual Review of Medicine 22: 305-326; 1971

10 Patten, B.M. A personal tribute to Dr. George C. Cotzias, clinician and scientist, Perspect. Biol. Med. 27:156-161; 1983.

11 Marberger H.; Huber, W.; Bartsch, G.; Schulte, T.; Swoboda, P. Orgotein: a new antiinflammatory metalloprotein drug evaluation of clinical efficacy and safety in inflammatory conditions of the urinary tract. Int. Urol. Nephrol. 6:61-74;1974

12 Proctor, P. H., Purine Activation of Oxygen, Master's thesis, University of Texas Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences, Houston, Tex., 1971.

13 Proctor P.; McGinness, J.E. Levodopa side-effects and the Lesch-Nyhan syndromeLancet. 2:1367; 1970

14 Proctor P. Relationship between alkaptonuria and parkinsonism Lancet 2:984; 1970

15 Proctor P. Psychosis, dyskinesia, and hyperpigmentation Lancet 1:1069; 1971

16 Proctor P. Concerning the mechanism of action of L-DOPA in Parkinsonism Biochem Med.4:357-379; 1970

17 Nyhan, W.L. Dopamine function in Lesch-Nyhan disease, Environ Health Perspect. 108 Suppl 3:409-411; 2000

18 Visser, J.E.; Smith, D.W.; Moy, S.S.; Breese, G.R.; Friedmann, T.; Rothstein J.D.; Jinnah, H.A. Oxidative stress and dopamine deficiency in a genetic mouse model of Lesch-Nyhan disease. Brain Res Dev Brain Res.133:127-139: 2002

19 Bavaresco C.S.; Chiarani, F.; Kolling, J.; Netto, C.A.; de Souza; Wyse, A.T. Biochemical effects of pretreatment with vitamins E and C in rats submitted to intrastriatal hypoxanthine administration. Neurochem Int. 52:1276-1283; 2008

20 Saugstad OD, Marklund SL. High activities of erythrocyte glutathione peroxidase in patients with the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. Acta Med. Scand. 224:281-285; 1988

21 Proctor P.H.; Kirpatrick D.S.; Morehead, L.A.; McGinness J.E.; Hilton, J.G.; Hokanson, J. Abstract and Discussion : Conference on Active Oxygen and Medicine, Honolulu, Hawaii, March 3-4 (1979) "Role of Active Oxygen Species in Ocular and Neurological Diseases".

22 Feig,D.I.; Kang, D.-H.; Johnson, R.J. Uric Acid and Cardiovascular Risk, NEJM 359:1811-1821; 2008

23 Proctor P.H., Uric acid: neuroprotective or neurotoxic?. Stroke 39:e88;2008

24 Seet RC, Kasiman K, Gruber J, Tang SY, Wong MC, Chang HM, Chan YH, Halliwell B, Chen CP. Is uric acid protective or deleterious in acute ischemic stroke? A prospective

cohort study. doi:10.1016/j.atherosclerosis.2009.08.012.

25 Lowrey JC. An unusual diet-derived inflammatory dermatosis in a Dalmatian dog responds to orgotein. Vet Med Small Anim Clin. 71:289�295; 1976.

26 Proctor, P, Kirkpatrick DS, and McGinness JE, Superoxide dismutase therapy in hyperuricaemic syndromes. Lancet, 2:95; 1978.

27 Proctor P, Similar Functions of Uric Acid and Ascorbate in Man ?. Nature 228:868; 1970.

28 McGinness, J.E., Mobility gaps: a mechanism for band gaps in melanins. Science 177:896-897; 1972.

29 McGinness, J.E.; Corry, P.: Proctor, P. Amorphous semiconductor switching in melanins. Science 183:853-855; 1974

30 McGinness, J.E.; Proctor, P.H.; Demopolous, H.B.; Hokinson,J.E.; Van,N.T. An in vivo enzymatic probe for superoxide and peroxide production by chemotherapeutic agents. In: Autor, A.P., ed. Pathology of Oxygen,, New York: Academic Press; 1984: 191-206

31 Bochner, B.R.; Lee, P.C.; Wilson, S.W.; Cutler, C.W.; Ames, B.N. AppppA and related adenylylated nucleotides are synthesized as a consequence of oxidation stress. Cell 37:225-232; 1984.

32 Bolto B.A.; McNeill R.;Weiss, D.E. Electronic Conduction in Polymers. III. Electronic Properties of Polypyrrole, Australian Journal of Chemistry 16:1090�1103; 1963

33 Inzelt,G., Historical Background (or there is nothing new under the Sun), chapter 8. E. Scholtz, ed. "Conducting Polymers". Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag; 2008: 265-269.

34 Nicolaus, R.A.; Parisi, G. The Nature of Animal Blacks. Atti Accademia Pontaniana XLIX, 27:197-233; 2000

35 Shirakawa H.; Louis E.L.; MacDiarmid A.G.; Chiang C.K.; and Heeger, A.J.; Synthesis of electrically conducting organic polymers: halogen derivatives of polyacetylene, (CH)x J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1977:578-580; 1977

36 Hush, N.S. An Overview of the First Half-Century of Molecular Electronics. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 1006:1�20; 2003.

37 �Organic Semiconductor (I/O), 1973 a melanin (polyacetylenes) bistable switch." at Organic semiconductors

38Commoner, B., Townsend, J and Pake, GE. Free radicals in biological materials. Nature 174, 689-691 (9 October 1954) | doi:10.1038/174689a0

39 Yuichiro Justin Suzukia, Henry Jay Formanb , and Alex Sevanianb, Review: Oxidants as Stimulators of Signal Transduction, Free Radic. Biol. Med. 22, 269�285 (1997), 10.1016/ S0891-5849(96)00275-4

39. Priel A, Ramos AJ, Tuszynski JA, Cantiello HF. A biopolymer transistor: electrical amplification by microtubules. Biophys J. 2006 Jun 15;90(12):4639-43. Epub 2006 Mar 24. PubMed PMID: 16565058; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC1471843.

40. Bettinger CJ, Bao Z. Biomaterials-Based Organic Electronic Devices. Polym Int. 2010 May 1;59(5):563-567. PubMed PMID: 20607127; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC2895275.